So, here I am in 2026, just trying to enjoy the timeless vistas of Red Dead Redemption 2, when I accidentally acquire the most loyal, and frankly unwanted, posse in the history of the American frontier. It all started with a simple shootout near camp. Next thing I know, Dutch van der Linde and Sadie Adler are following me around like lost puppies, or more accurately, like two highly armed, morally complex shadows. This isn't a mission. This is my life now. I’ve become an accidental gang leader with a VIP entourage I never asked for, all thanks to a glitch that refuses to quit.

dutch-and-sadie-won-t-leave-me-alone-my-accidental-red-dead-redemption-2-gang-entourage-image-0

The beauty—and occasional chaos—of a game as vast as Red Dead Redemption 2 is that even years after release, it's still full of surprises. Rockstar built a world so detailed and immense that a few quirky bugs were bound to slip through the cracks. Most are harmless, some are hilarious, and a select few, like my new permanent followers, fundamentally alter the solo cowboy experience. It's a testament to the game's living world that these glitches feel less like errors and more like bizarre, emergent storytelling. Remember that other player who found a glitch that turned enemy corpses into towering, monolithic piles of weapons? Yeah, the law of the West is more of a gentle suggestion in this game's code.

Let me paint the scene. I’m Arthur Morgan, a man who values his solitude, riding through the Heartlands. I glance back. There’s Dutch, philosophizing about loyalty and plans, trotting along on his horse. A few paces behind, Sadie is giving me that intense, ‘I-will-cut-someone’ stare she’s so famous for. We’re not en route to rob a bank or enact a complex revenge plot. I was literally just going to go fishing. The game doesn't have a formal ‘follower’ system for free roam, so their unwavering dedication is both impressive and deeply unsettling. It’s like having your strict boss and your most vengeful coworker insist on joining you for a quiet weekend trip.

The real fun began when I decided to test the limits of my new ‘goons,’ as one optimistic observer online called them. I cautiously committed a minor crime—let’s say I ‘borrowed’ a horse that wasn’t technically mine. The law showed up. I drew my weapon, hesitant. Before I could even fire a shot, BANG! BANG! Dutch and Sadie opened up without a moment's hesitation. There was no ‘Have some goddamn faith, Arthur!’ debate. Just immediate, overwhelming support. Their AI was stuck in ‘protect the leader’ mode, turning my petty larceny into a full-blown military engagement. The table below sums up the surreal dynamic:

Situation Normal RDR2 Gameplay My Glitched Gameplay
Peaceful Ride Solitude, maybe a song. A leadership summit on horseback.
Minor Crime A bounty, a chase. A coordinated tactical response.
Going Fishing A quiet moment. Being supervised by a philosopher and a force of nature.

So, how did this happen? The internet, in its infinite wisdom, provided the perfect explanation. It turns out the trigger is surprisingly simple. If you get into a firefight near your gang's camp, your comrades will rush out to help you. The game, in that moment, temporarily tags them as part of your active party. Here’s the kicker: if you have the audacity to die while they’re helping you, the game sometimes gets confused. It forgets to remove that ‘party member’ tag when you respawn. So, when you ride out of camp, they just… come along. Indefinitely. It’s a digital version of forgetting to hang up the phone, but instead of an awkward silence, you get two extra outlaws.

Living with this glitch in 2026 is a unique experience. With the original Red Dead Redemption finally on PC and any potential sequel still a distant dream on the horizon, we’re in an era of appreciating the classics in new ways. My playthrough has become a weird, unofficial ‘Gang Manager Simulator.’ 😅

  • The Pros: I am virtually unstoppable in any combat scenario. Want to clear out a gang hideout? Done. My posse handles it with extreme prejudice.

  • The Cons: Stealth is impossible. Trying to sneak through a mission is like trying to sneak with a marching band. Their commentary is constant. Every animal I skin is met with a profound statement from Dutch or a gruff observation from Sadie.

It’s a hilarious, memorable quirk that the developers never intended. In a weird way, it adds a layer of camaraderie the main story sometimes rushes past. Sure, Dutch’s plans are often terrible, and Sadie’s thirst for vengeance is all-consuming, but out here in the wild, they’ve got my back. Even if it’s because a line of code got lost. For any player looking to replicate this ‘feature,’ the formula is simple: Start a fight near camp, be terrible enough to die in it, and enjoy your new, permanent friends. Just don’t expect any peace and quiet on those long rides to Saint Denis.